The book of mormon provided multiple official and unofficial witnesses who corroborated aspects of josephs account. The witnesses to the book of mormon didnt sign their names. It is one thing for a guy to claim visions, but it gains a lot more credibility when a dozen other men swear they the same thing and know it for a fact. Charting the book of mormon, 1999 welch, welch, farms chart 168 explanation source the testimony of three witnesses in the 1830 edition of the book of mormon was originally included at the end of the book, as a final seal of its veracity. The three witnesses, unlike the eight witnesses, were shown the plates by a heavenly messenger, not joseph smith. The eight witnesses were one of the two groups of witnesses who made statements stating that they had seen the golden plates which joseph smith jr. Half way down the first page marks the beginning of the testimony of the 3 witnesses and concludes on the top of the second page with their signatures. It is inconclusive if the witnesses actually saw plates or if they only claimed to see them. These men signed statements declaring the book of mormon was true, and that.
Of the eight witnesses, irr notes, all eight had close personal ties to joseph smiths familyfour were david whitmers brothers, a fifth was married to a whitmer sister, and josephs father and two brothers made up the remaining three. Why didnt the book of mormon witnesses sign their testimony. By analogy, one of your children wants to publish a book of family letters pertaining to a deceased grandparent. Does anyone know if any of the witnesses of the bom actually. Investigating the book of mormon witnesses deseret book. Bofm witnesses presentation provides a spiritual and temporal witness of the realities of the book of mormon. An earlier group of witnesses who said they had seen the plates were called the three witnesses. The book of mormon contains two sets of joint statements written by joseph smith for those who claimed to have seen the gold plates. Book of mormon witnesses, we dont have their signatures. None of the eleven book of mormon witnesses ever signed their testimonies.
Some latterday saint historians and i believe that the witnesses signed their name to the original testimonies that were part of the original book of mormon manuscript, and that oliver cowdery just copied the n. Grandins wayne sentinel newspaper publishes book of mormon title page, a requirement for, along with derisive commentary about the project. Much confusion surrounds the issue of who actually saw or signed what, where and when. The 1840 and 1842 nauvoo editions were the last two editions printed in. The three and eight witnesses to the book of mormon.
The evidence left by the book of mormon witnesses is rich, varied, and uneven, including the following. Those who would defend traditional beliefs about mormon origins often turn to the testimonies of 11 men. These witnessesoliver cowdery, david whitmer, and martin harristestified that they had heard gods. We talk at length about our assumptions that the three witnesses has a spiritual event, that the eight witnesses had a physical event, whether their experience was consistent, and how the institutional church may have. Three witnesses the three witnesses are david whitmer, oliver cowdery, and martin harris, who mortgaged his farm to finance the first printing of the book of mormon.
Investigating the book of mormon witnesses kindle edition. Book of mormon spiritual and temporal witnesses presentation. We talk at length about our assumptions that the three witnesses has a spiritual event, that the eight witnesses had a physical event, whether their experience was consistent, and how the institutional church may have expressed certainty about the boundaries and constructs of their. The world was not left with joseph smiths testimony alone. Ancient documents often needed the signatures of witnesses in order to be considered authentic or legally binding.
The book of mormon provided multiple official and unofficial witnesses who. Did the 8 mormon witnesses really sign an affidavit. Richard lloyd anderson in investigating the book of mormon witnesses salt lake city. Many critics of the book of mormon witnesses say that the witnesses of the book of mormon denied their written testimonies in statements to different people over the years.
Three witnesses oliver cowdery, david whitmer, and martin harris declared an angel of god appeared to them and showed them the book of mormon plates and they heard the voice of the lord pronounce that. Joseph smith would put the seer stone into a hat, and put his face in the hat, drawing it closely around his face to exclude the light. Gunnell goes on to quote a letter written in 1844 by phineas young to brigham young, martin harris is a firm believer in shakerism, says his testimony is greater than it was of the book of mormon martin harris witness and benefactor to the book of mormon, wayne c. Theoretically, if a book comes out with a false attestation the purported witness would disavow the attestation. The most significant witnesses are the three witnesses and the eight witnesses, all of whom allowed their names to be used on two separate statements included with the book of mormon. Critics have long tried to dismiss or destroy the witnesses witness. Some mormons will agree that all three witnesses denied the book of mormon but came back to deny their denial. Here are some critics thoughts on that thanks to gary porter and craig criddle for these. Did the book of mormon witnesses really see what they claimed. Book of mormon witnesses all later denied its truthfulness. None of the signatures promoted by the church were penned by the witnesses. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading investigating the book of mormon witnesses. Did the 8 mormon witnesses really sign an affidavit stating. There are only two of the witnesses to that book now living, to wit.
Book of mormon witnesses, we dont have their signatures references 1 testimony of eight witnesses, june 1829, 2 us declaration of independence, july 1776, library of congress for. Lds book of mormon 1830 ed signed joseph smith witnesses. By providing the testimonies of witnesses and including them at the end of the book of mormon, joseph smith was following not only the ancient pattern called for by nephi, but also the guidance and inspiration of the lord. The signatures of the witnesses are typically found on the back of the document, on the sealed part in early times, and on the open part in later times. Facts on the book of mormon witnesses part 2 mormons in. The only visual record the lds church has is the printers copy made by oliver cowdery, all in his handwriting, including the signatures of the three men. The book of mormon, translation, errors, and even the. Today chris and clay join me again for a roundtable discussion about the eleven witnesses to the book of mormon.
But none of the witnesses did so and, as such, confirmed and ratified their statements. The historical narrative surrounding the book of mormon witnesses presents a. The final of the three witnesses is oliver cowdery, who served as scribe for 80% of the book of mormon. Some of the witnesses of the book of mormon, who handled the plates and conversed with the angels of god, were afterwards left to doubt and to disbelieve that they had ever seen an angel. Yes, it is true that the signatures on the extant manuscript page that we have for the testimony of the eight and three witnesses were done by oliver cowdery. Book of mormon witnesses facts, controversies, and contradictions. The first edition of the book of mormon featured two testimonials. Three witnesses oliver cowdery, david whitmer, and martin harris declared an angel of god appeared to them and showed them the book of mormon plates and they heard the voice of the lord pronounce. May 04, 2015 the original manuscript of the book of mormon, which supposedly contained the original signatures, was placed by smith in the cornerstone of the nauvoo house in 1841. When i was a missionary, my understanding and impression from looking at the testimony of the three and eight witnesses in the book of mormon was that the statements were legally binding documents in which the names represented signatures on the original document similar to what you would see on the original us declaration of independence. Richard lloyd anderson, personal writings of the book of mormon witnesses, in book of mormon authorship revisited.
When i was a missionary, my understanding and impression from looking at the testimony of the three and eight witnesses in the book of mormon was that the signatures and statements were legally binding documents in which the names represented signatures on the original document similar to those you would see on the original us declaration of. Getting a replica book of mormon bound either by handsewing or smythsewing a slightly newer version of hand stitching, by machine, adding the additional strength of adhesive gives this book the stitching that a good replica deserves. The book of mormon witnesses are a group of contemporaries of joseph smith who claimed to. A church that obsesses so much about records is amazingly cavalier about hanging onto important original documentse.
Based on the body of available evidence we dont really know if the eleven book of mormon witnesses ever signed their testimony or not. Witnesses to the book of mormon place their signatures on their testimonies. Vogels main treatments of this subject are in his early mormon documents, 3. His 1981 book investigating the book of mormon witnesses explores the lives and characters of the witnesses in great detail, but nothing is said about their propensities for visionary experience. Three witnesses oliver cowdery, david whitmer, and martin harris declared an angel of god appeared to them and showed them the book of mormon plates and they heard the voice of the lord pronounce that joseph smiths translation had been accomplished. Does anyone know if any of the witnesses of the bom. David whitmer, one of the book of mormon s three witnesses, said if you believe my testimony to the book of mormon.
Richard lloyd anderson presents evidence from original sources on each of the eleven witnesses and concludes. The testimony of the eight witnesses was first published at the end of the 1830 edition of the book of mormon and has been printed in nearly every edition since, although most subsequent editions moved the statement to the front of the book and included minor grammatical corrections. An ongoing series of articles on some common and recurring weak arguments that christians make against mormonism. The earliest documented statement of the three witnessesoliver cowdery, david whitmer, and martin harrisis their statement in the handwriting of oliver cowdery subsequently published in the 1830 edition of the book of mormon.
Based on the body of available evidence we dont really know if the eleven book of mormon witnesses ever signed. Evaluating the book of mormon witnesses book of mormon. Obviously, the book of mormon witnesses consented to the witness statement and agreed with it. The original manuscript of the book of mormon, which supposedly contained the original signatures, was placed by smith in the cornerstone of the nauvoo house in 1841. Faithpromoting material about the book of mormon witnesses like cowdery claims. In this carefully researched, thoughtprovoking book, dr. An important episode associated with the translation and coming forth of the book of mormon was the experience of two sets of witnesseseleven totalwho, among other things, claimed to have actually seen the gold plates, which were delivered by the angel moroni to joseph smith. The testimonies of the book of mormon witnesses religious. Aug 22, 20 book of mormon witnesses, we dont have their signatures. The historical narrative surrounding the book of mormon witnesses presents a labyrinth of conflicting statements, many provided decades after the fact by those not present during the events. Cowderys elevated status as second elder and witness to the book of mormon was eventually lost amid accusations of adultery and theft. The book of mormon, translation, errors, and even the witnesses. Investigating the book of mormon witnesses kindle edition by anderson, richard lloyd. The statement of the 3 witnesses for the book of mormon was a single statement signed by all three men.
In september, 1878, in company with apostle orson pratt, the writer visited david whitmer, at richmond, ray county, missouri. Statements clearly traced to the witnesses verify the testimonies printed in the book of mormon. However, since most of the original manuscript did not survive, this would explain why the transcription of the original version of the testimonies. Jul 11, 2011 richard anderson investigating the book of mormon witnesses, 1981 admits the third handnature of this account, but still uses it as evidence, attributing its most accurate telling to george q.
David whitmer, one of the book of mormon witnesses, explained the process. Historical evidence has led many people to question the authenticity of the book of mormon and the credibility of joseph smiths story. Additional information on the individual witnesses and their statements are available in the maxwell institutes digital collection. The names of oliver cowdery, david whitmer, and martin harris are familiar to most of us, notably because of their role as witnesses to the reality of the book of mormon. Roberts on the view of the hebrews parallels with the book of mormon emphasis mine. Evaluating the book of mormon witnesses book of mormon central. References 1 testimony of eight witnesses, june 1829. Evaluating the book of mormon witnesses religious studies center.
Grant palmer, an insiders view of mormon origins salt lake city, utah. The most unusual tribute to this book of mormon witness came in an obituary written thirtyfour years before his death. But evidence suggests that the two statements, along with the personal signatures by each of the witnesses, were likely included at the very end of the original manuscript of the book of mormon. Cowdery was a third cousin to lucy smith, while joseph smith sr. Book of mormonwitnessessignatures on their testimonies. Facts on the book of mormon witnesses part 2 mormons. All of the living book of mormon witnesses, except oliver cowdery, later accepted james strangs prophetic claim of being josephs true successor and joined his church. For instance, all 11 witnesses to the book of mormon shared a common worldview of second sight, magic, and treasure digging. He was excommunicated from the church in 1838 and forced to leave the area. The author, richard lloyd anderson, gives many historical details about the statements of such critics and the sources and background of their statements. The book of mormon witnesses are a group of contemporaries of joseph smith who claimed to have seen the golden plates from which smith translated the book of mormon. The witness testimonies are some of the best secular evidences for the book of mormons truth. Photograph of the signatures of the eight witnesses to the book of mormon. Witnesses of the book of mormon church of jesus christ.
While this was a late recollection on cannons part, anderson justifies using it by stating that cannon had a remarkable intellect and a. Although some of these witnesses later left strangs church, none of them is known to have ever denied their testimony as given in the book of the law. Throughout their lives, none of the witnesses of the book of mormon ever denied their. Jun 24, 2019 the names of oliver cowdery, david whitmer, and martin harris are familiar to most of us, notably because of their role as witnesses to the reality of the book of mormon.
We can compare the witnesses for the book of mormon to the witnesses of manuscript found. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Modern mormon spin doctors write all kinds of articles claiming that the witnesses may have denied the mormon church but they never the book of mormon. Here are a series of quotes which may interest some about the supposed book of mormon witnesses. Debunking fairmormon letter to a ces director witnesses. For reasons that are not completely clear, smith and cowderys relationship soured. Documents bearing the signatures of the three witnesses, from left, oliver cowdery, martin harris and david whitmer, are displayed friday, feb. The testimonies of the witnesses printed in the book of mormon offer. It is altogether probable that these two bookspriests wonders of nature and providence, 1824.
180 1457 1123 81 218 1368 1087 1375 452 153 16 841 1143 18 34 40 396 1498 687 989 1111 1000 40 907 1459 1073 377 61 426 726 982 1016